Privacy Tech Firms Warn: France’s Encryption and VPN Laws Threaten Online Privacy

France’s latest legislative proposals have sparked significant concerns among privacy-focused technology firms, cybersecurity experts, and digital rights organizations. The proposed amendments to existing laws aim to mandate encryption backdoors in secure messaging services, allowing law enforcement to access decrypted user communications within 72 hours upon request. Additionally, the legislation seeks to compel VPN providers to block access to specific websites, a move backed by major rightsholders in the entertainment industry.

Critics argue that these measures could severely weaken cybersecurity, making encrypted communication services vulnerable to cybercriminals, foreign adversaries, and mass surveillance. Privacy advocates warn that mandating backdoors compromises encryption for all users—not just criminals—creating exploitable vulnerabilities. Similarly, forcing VPN providers to restrict access could set a dangerous precedent for internet censorship, likening it to restrictive policies seen in authoritarian regimes.

With the French National Assembly set to review these proposals, the debate continues over whether these laws serve public safety or pose a fundamental threat to digital privacy and online freedom. The outcome could have long-term implications for encryption policies, VPN regulations, and internet security across Europe and beyond.

Inside France’s Controversial Privacy Laws

Encryption Backdoors: A Risk to All Users

An amendment to France’s “Narcotrafic” law proposes that encrypted messaging providers must decrypt messages within 72 hours upon law enforcement request. Companies that fail to comply could face severe penalties:

• €1.5 million fine for individuals
• Up to 2% of annual global turnover for companies

Privacy-focused email provider Tuta (formerly Tutanota) has strongly opposed the proposal, emphasizing that backdoors weaken security for everyone, not just criminals.

Security experts argue that such backdoors could be exploited by cybercriminals, foreign adversaries, and malicious hackers, posing a global risk to encrypted communications. Additionally, the proposal raises concerns about potential conflicts with GDPR and Germany’s IT security laws, as European regulations prioritize strong encryption protections.

VPN Providers Face Website Blocking Orders

Alongside encryption laws, French rightsholders Canal+ and the French Football League (LFP) have taken legal action to force VPN providers to block piracy-related websites. The VPN Trust Initiative (VTI), which includes members such as ExpressVPN, NordVPN, and PureVPN, has denounced the move, warning of unintended consequences for privacy and cybersecurity.

“Focusing on content-neutral tools like VPNs rather than addressing the sources of illegal content not only fails to combat piracy but creates and inflicts collateral damage to cybersecurity and privacy, putting users at risk.”

Privacy advocates fear that such laws could set a dangerous precedent, paving the way for broader government censorship of the internet.

The Growing Global Trend of Online Surveillance

France’s new proposals reflect an increasing global push for government control over online communications. Recent examples include Apple’s decision to remove iCloud end-to-end encryption in the UK after the government demanded access to user data, and Sweden’s proposed law to access users’ private messages on encrypted apps like Signal.

While no VPN provider has officially announced an exit from the French market, if these laws pass, some services may reconsider their operations, similar to past VPN withdrawals from India and Pakistan due to privacy-compromising regulations.

How These Laws Could Impact Users

If these laws pass, the implications for online privacy and security could be severe:

• Encrypted communication services may be forced to weaken security, exposing user data to cyber threats.
• VPN providers could be pressured into restricting access to information, impacting internet freedom.
• France may face legal challenges regarding encryption regulations under GDPR.

Final Thoughts: A Critical Moment for Digital Privacy in France

France’s proposed encryption and VPN laws represent a significant turning point in the global debate over privacy, cybersecurity, and government surveillance. While lawmakers argue that these measures are necessary for law enforcement and anti-piracy efforts, privacy advocates warn that the long-term consequences could be severe. Mandating encryption backdoors could weaken security for millions of users, leaving sensitive data exposed to cybercriminals, hostile foreign actors, and mass surveillance programs. Similarly, forcing VPN providers to block access to certain websites could pave the way for broader government control over online content.

With the French National Assembly set to deliberate on these proposals, the stakes are high. If passed, these laws could reshape encryption policies and VPN regulations across Europe, influencing other nations to adopt similar measures. Conversely, strong opposition from privacy advocates, technology firms, and legal experts may force reconsideration or legal challenges under EU privacy regulations such as GDPR.

Protect Your Privacy with Nexanet

In a world where governments and corporations are increasingly seeking access to personal data, protecting your online privacy is more critical than ever. Nexanet offers industry-leading encryption tools, VPN services, and dark web monitoring to help individuals and businesses safeguard their digital rights.

Stay protected. Stay private. Stay secure.